America's most-cited legal scholar quit the bench over the poor man's appeal
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Bloomberg Law · https://news.bloomberglaw.com/legal-exchange-insights-and-commentary/posner-fearsome-on-the-bench-showed-us-the-fun-in-inquiry
Richard Posner taught judges to count costs, then left the bench saying his court skimmed appeals from people without lawyers. Exodus named the poor man's lawsuit long before.
You shall not deny justice to your poor people in their lawsuits.
Exodus 23:6
Richard Posner died in Chicago on November 10, at 87. He was the most-cited legal scholar of the late 20th century, the father of law and economics, who taught lawyers to ask what a rule costs and who pays. In 36 years on the federal appeals court in Chicago, he wrote some 3,300 opinions.
So it surprised people when, in September 2017, he left the bench on a day's notice over the least efficient work in the building. These were appeals from people with no lawyer, who had written their own papers. Staff attorneys read them first and wrote memos recommending an outcome, which, Posner told The New York Times, the judges mostly rubber-stamped. Most judges, he said, saw such litigants as "kind of trash not worth the time of a federal judge." He had proposed reviewing every staff memo before it reached a panel. The head of the staff attorney program agreed, he said, but his colleagues turned him down.
His court disputed his account. Chief Judge Diane Wood wrote that "the judges and our staff attorneys take great care with pro se filings," and all 11 judges backed her. Posner was blunt, and he could be wrong. Whoever was right about his court, the book of Exodus had named the risk long before. Its law code was given to people just out of slavery, who knew what it was to have no one speak for them.
Of all the places a court can fail, that law points to the poor man's lawsuit.
It asks for the same fair hearing everyone gets, and it marks the poor man's case as the one most easily turned aside. Posner's charge shows what that can look like today. A bad verdict can be appealed, but a file nobody really read leaves almost no trace. Job, defending his life to his friends, described a just man this way:
Job 29:16I was a father to the needy. The cause of him who I didn't know, I searched out.
Searching out a stranger's case takes time, the one thing an efficient court is built to save. Posner spent his own on it after he retired, opening a center to help people without lawyers. It closed in July 2019 with about $8,800 in the bank and $8,000 in debt. By then he had been diagnosed with Alzheimer's, and he later moved to a nursing facility.
Near the end of his career, the man who asked what everything costs decided a stranger's case was worth a federal judge's time. A fair hearing on paper means little if no one reads the file. Exodus names the poor man's lawsuit as the place justice is easiest to turn aside, and Job names what keeps it from happening: someone willing to search the case out.
Sources
Judge Richard A. Posner Has Died. His Influence in Law Was Beyond Compare.
The New York Times
Judge, Economist Richard Posner Dies at 87
Wall Street Journal
Judge Posner's Last Lesson for the Judiciary
The Free Press
Law School Mourns the Passing of Richard A. Posner, Senior Lecturer, Law and Economics Pioneer, and Former Federal Appellate Judge
University of Chicago Law School
Why did Richard Posner retire? A fight over people without lawyers, then Alzheimer's
Nacionale
Richard Posner, prolific legal scholar and outspoken appeals court judge, dies at 87
AP News
